Notes on Zen Buddhism
November 18, 2002
A. Origins. Boddhidharma (called
Daruma
in Japan), 28th Patriarch of Buddhism (that is, 28th official leader of
the sect, or `dharma successor', after Gautama Buddha himself. Supposedly
he travelled from India to China as a missionary to carry the Bhuddhist
message. The
Dhyana (`meditation') (or Ch'an in Chinese and
Zen
in Japanese) sect was claimed to come from India. But it has borrowed much
from traditional Chinese thought (especially `Taoism'). Boddhidharma
is said to have arrived in China in 520 CE. Buddhism of other sects had
existed at some level in China since 270 CE. Boddhidharma, (according to
legend) spent 9 years sitting in a cave in China meditating before he took
his first student. This is what he said his message was:
-
`Zen is a special transmission outside the scriptures'; (there is
no sutra for these ideas)
-
`No dependence upon words and characters'; (these cannot help but misrepresent
the truth you seek)
-
`Direct pointing at the soul of man' (no intermediary systems, such as
`intellectualization')
-
`Seeing into one's own nature and attainment of Buddhahood.' (Zen is for
you
and
your salvation as an individual; it's not about your family)
![]()

Daruma has been a symbol for Japanese of perseverance. So
this little doll on the right, an image of Daruma (Boddhidharma) is frequently
seen in shops or student dorms in Japan to encourage perseverance in the
face of difficulties.
B. Classical Chinese Religions.
-
Confucianism -Emphasis on social order and hierarchy, on
honoring one's ancestors,and on the importance of mutual obligations between
superiors (eg, fathers, lords and emperor) and inferiors (wives, children,
lower lord's, etc).
-
Confucius (Kung Fu-Tzu) lived around 600 BCE at the end of a long period
of destructive wars. Zen Buddhism acquired many Confucian ideas, such as
the primacy of loyalty to one's lord and/or teacher.
-
Importance of serving Heaven via family duties.
-
Rituals of piety, loyalty, hierarchy
-
Heaven and salvation are/should be in this world
-
Fulfilling one’s duty to honor our seniors and create descendants
-
Perfecting the individual in society; and perfecting society to support
individuals
(supports responsible citizenship)
-
Zen as Antidote to Confucianism - ``One must not forget
the social context of Zen. It is primarily a way of liberation for
those who have mastered the disciplines of social convention. Zen is a
medicine for the ill effects of this conditioning, for the mental paralysis
and anxiety which come from excessive self-consciousness. It must
be seen against the background of societies regulated by the principles
of Confucianism, with their heavy stress on propriety and punctilious ritual.''
- from Alan Watts (The Way of Zen, 1957, p142):
-
Taoism - Founded around the same time as Confucianism. It
offered a mystical view of life. The first line of the Tao Te Ching
(look at my excerpts
from it) has been translated as ``The Tao that can be spoken of is
not the true Tao''. The original meaning of Tao is `path' but in this religion
it can mean Truth, Nature, the Absolute or the Law, that is, `the way things
really are'.
-
(Lao Tzu: Tao Te Ching) – relates man to all-pervading principle of life,
the mystical Tao
-
How to gain centering and serenity for the individual; goal of immortality
-
Equal importance of tiny and great (the serf and the lord)
-
Spirituality of the everyday; of nature (eg, peeling potatoes is as important
as writing a book, painting a scroll or a swordfight with an enemy) All
are important and worth doing with spiritual intent.
-
The Tao can be experienced, but not described in words.
-
Truth can be reached only through the comprehension of opposites (eg, black
and white, sound and silence, yin and yang).
-
Nature just happens; don’t force it, follow it
Zen is so greatly influenced by Taoism that it is sometimes said
that it could be called `Japanese-Buddhist Taoism'.
Buddhism changed to suit the Chinese:
1. Chinese interest was first in medicine and specific methods
to prolong life
2. Acceptance took many hundred years. Objections were to vegetarianism;
pleasure renunciation; head-shaving, clerical celibacy, etc.
3. The optimistic, nirvana-oriented practice (re boddhisattvas)
was more appealing than the 4 Noble Truths.
Taoism seeks ways to lengthen life (including magic ways) and make it satisfying,
while Confucianism seeks ethical heaven on earth via duty. But both
affirm the positive nature of life on this earth; neither says much about
any future `lives’. Thus, from this perspective, the 4 Noble Truths seem
very pessimistic indeed! So it took a long time for Buddhism to take
hold in China though, in the process, Buddhism absorbed many principles
of Confucianism and Taoism. Naturally, Japanese Zen also includes
much Confucian and Taoist thinking.
C. Religious Principles of Zen
-
Buddha nature is within you, but you have to find it. Meditation is essential
to achieve this.
-
Sit, sit, sit. Learn how to be mentally empty. (Unlike other kinds of Buddhist
meditation, don't focus on any `meditation object.') Attend to everything,
but not to something. Do not try to `apprehend' the world or the mind,
`mindlessness', `emptiness of mind'.
-
Spontaneous action, direct bodily and mental engagement with the world,
simple acts (eg., chopping wood) are important and spiritual acts, almost
as important as meditation. Hence Zen has suggestions for improving fighting
skills. A famous saying (of Yun-men): `In walking just walk. In
sitting, just sit. Above all, don't wobble.' Master Rinzai said
``When hungry, I eat. When tired I sleep. Fools laugh at me. The wise understand’
-
Maintain direct connection with everything around you, yet do not identify
anything as `yours'. Be directly involved in the world. But your actions
should just happen by themselves, without forethought or intention. Be
cool and impassive yet be ready for anything. A favorite image is
the moon reflected from a river: the moon remains still on the water while
the river beneath hurries steadily past. You be the moon, while the river
is your life.
D. Zen and Japanese Arts. Zen-based esthetics
has greatly influenced Japanese styles of art since the 13th century and,
since WWII, many American arts as well.
-
Ceramics with earthy coloring and rough texture -- no garish colors
and detailed lines. Overall simplicity and rusticness; A delight in primitive-looking,
unpretentious pottery, not delicate tracery or shiny glazes found in many
Chinese (and some kinds of Japanese) styles. Zen-influenced ceramics have
been stylish in the US for the past 40 years.
-
Gardens that are `artificially natural-looking' -- mossy, with curving
walkways, irregular ponds (sometimes with a small bridge or two), mostly
foliage rather than flowers, and decorated with natural rocks and sometimes
gravel beds (a style also emulated in the US since WWII.). An absolute
rejection of bilateral symmetry and straight lines.
-
Painting focussing on monochrome ink with a minimal number of brush
strokes.
-
Calligraphy (that is, drawing written characters artistically with
a brush) that is aggressive and bold presenting a careless, casual appearance
(but demanding great amounts of practice and skill).
-
Tea Ceremony. A stylized ritual for serving and drinking
whisked tea - practiced by monks and nobles. The ritual space (the little
tea house) is carefully specified. The actions and speech of the guests
(3-4 people) and the host are almost completely `scripted'. The great
tea-master makes subtle choices about what scroll would be displayed (often
a short poem in calligraphy), what the flower arrangement will be and which
tea-bowls and other utinsels to use. Here is a description (with some pictures)
of the tea ceremony.
Tea, native to China, became widespread in Japan starting around the year
1000 CE, initially in monasteries to help monks avoid slipping into sleep
while meditating.
-
In poetry too, they preferred short, simple epigrammatic poems that
primarily create a vivid image - often a meloncholy one. The haiku
form of 16 syllables was developed by a Zen monk (Bassho) in the 17th century.
The form has 5 syllables in the first line, 7 in the second and 5 in the
third. This poem one may be the very first haiku - and certainly
the most famous of them all.
Furu ike ya.
The old pond!
Kawazu tobikomu
A frog jumps,
Mizu no oto
Splash of water.
On a withered branch
A crow is perched
In autumn evening.
A fallen flower
Returning to the branch?
It was a butterfly.
A long night
The sound of the water
Says what I think.
E. Zen and Warfare. Boddhidharma was said to
have taught martial arts to his students and is said to have written a
couple books (that is, scrolls) on this topic. These methods evolved into
jiu-jitsu
and aikido in Japan and tai kwon do in Korea.
In the 11th century Zen became popular with shoguns and samurai. Training
in martial skills, such as swordsmanship and archery, emphasized Zen ideas
as essential components to success. Read some quotes from D. T. Suzuki
on Zen
and swordplay. (Also recommended: `Zen and the Art of Archery'
by Eugen Herrigel. 1953) It seems like maybe `The Force' in Star
Wars may be modelled after these ideas.
F. The Koan is a teaching device, like a
riddle, a paradoxical use of language (much like the Tao Te-Ching).
See some examples on the
Koan Page. These were used as teaching devices for student monks
in some Zen sects. The goal was to help the student to be enlightened,
to `get it', perhaps in a sudden insight, and then convey that enlightenment
to the master. Such use of language (along with poetry) makes sense
if you don't trust language to get anything right.
G. Language as a Source of Difficulty in Zen.
It was pointed out that linguistic description (and conscious thought as
well) always schematize and simplify the world we describe. You can
never describe the world as it really is; but only describe a few things
that you believe are relevant to the purposes at hand. Thus, the linguistic
characterization will force you to miss things that might be important.
Or it may force you to make a distinction that really isn't interesting
or important (as in the following Zen joke).
Zen Story: Two monks were arguing about
a flag. `The flag is flapping,’ said one. `No’ said the other, `The wind
is flapping’. The argument went back and forth. The Master happened to
be passing by. He told them ``Not the wind, not the flag. Your minds are
flapping’.
[The point is that flap is just a word - so it doesn't matter
how you use it. Pay attention to the real event in the world,
not to how you may describe it.]
Conclusion. Zen was heavily influenced
by Chinese culture but adapted well to Japan. In the US today, Zen
is having a kind of renaiscance. Since the 1930s, many Americans
have found this style of religious practice attractive. In fact,
it seems that many ideas and esthetic tastes from Zen have become part
of American culture now, eg, in gardens, ceramics, modern poetry
and mystical ideas about ``the Force''. It does not seem, though,
that the Zen critique of language has found much fertile soil in the US,
nor is there apparently any Americanization of the koan.